Skip to Main Content

NYC Subway Slip and Fall Accidents: Suing the MTA for Your Injuries


The New York City subway system serves over 5 million riders daily, making it one of the world’s busiest transit networks. Unfortunately, NYC subway accidents are far too common, with MTA slip and fall incidents occurring regularly throughout the system. If you’ve been injured in a subway slip and fall accident, you may have grounds to sue the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) for compensation.

Common Causes of MTA Slip and Fall Accidents

NYC subway slip and fall accidents can happen anywhere within the transit system, from station platforms to subway cars themselves. Understanding the common causes helps establish liability in your case:

Wet and Slippery Surfaces: The most frequent cause of MTA accidents involves slippery conditions created by:

  • Water leaks from aging infrastructure
  • Spilled beverages and food
  • Cleaning chemicals and maintenance activities
  • Rain and snow tracked in by passengers
  • Condensation from air conditioning systems

Defective Stairs and Escalators: Many subway stations feature aging infrastructure with dangerous conditions:

  • Broken or uneven steps
  • Missing handrails or grab bars
  • Malfunctioning escalators
  • Poor lighting creates visibility hazards
  • Worn or damaged stair treads

Platform Hazards: NYC subway platform accidents frequently result from:

  • Gaps between trains and platforms
  • Uneven platform surfaces
  • Debris and litter are creating tripping hazards
  • Overcrowding is pushing passengers into dangerous areas
  • Missing or inadequate warning signs

Poor Maintenance: The MTA’s failure to properly maintain facilities contributes to many subway slip and fall cases:

  • Delayed repairs to known hazards
  • Inadequate cleaning protocols
  • Insufficient inspection schedules
  • Failure to address recurring problems

Legal Challenges in Suing the MTA

Suing the MTA for slip and fall injuries presents unique legal challenges that require experienced representation. The MTA enjoys certain legal protections as a government entity, but injured passengers still have rights.

Notice Requirements: New York law requires specific procedures when filing claims against government entities like the MTA:

90-Day Notice: You must file a formal notice of claim within 90 days of your accident

Detailed Information: The notice must include specific details about your accident, injuries, and damages

Strict Deadlines: Missing the 90-day deadline can bar your claim entirely

Sovereign Immunity Limitations: While the MTA has some immunity from lawsuits, it can still be held liable for:

  • Negligent maintenance of facilities
  • Failure to warn of known dangers
  • Creating hazardous conditions
  • Inadequate safety protocols

Proving Negligence: Successful MTA slip and fall lawsuits require proving:

  • The MTA knew or should have known about the dangerous condition
  • They failed to fix the hazard within a reasonable time
  • Their negligence directly caused your injuries
  • You suffered actual damages from the accident

Types of Injuries in NYC Subway Accidents

NYC subway slip and fall accidents often result in serious injuries due to hard surfaces and crowded conditions:

Fractures and Broken Bones: Falls on concrete platforms and metal stairs frequently cause:

  • Hip and pelvis fractures (especially in elderly passengers)
  • Wrist and arm breaks from trying to break falls
  • Ankle and foot fractures from uneven surfaces
  • Spinal compression fractures

Head and Brain Injuries: Subway head injuries can be particularly severe:

  • Concussions from falls on hard surfaces
  • Traumatic brain injuries requiring long-term care
  • Skull fractures from impacts with stairs or platforms
  • Facial injuries and dental damage

Soft Tissue Injuries: Even “minor” falls can cause significant soft tissue damage:

  • Back and neck injuries
  • Torn ligaments and muscles
  • Herniated discs
  • Chronic pain conditions

Building a Strong MTA Lawsuit

NYC subway accident lawyers understand the specific evidence needed to win cases against the MTA:

Incident Documentation: Immediate evidence collection is crucial:

  • Photographs of the accident scene and hazardous conditions
  • Witness contact information and statements
  • MTA incident reports and employee statements
  • Medical documentation of your injuries
  • Surveillance footage from subway cameras

Maintenance Records: Proving the MTA’s knowledge of dangerous conditions requires:

  • Maintenance logs showing delayed repairs
  • Previous incident reports at the same location
  • Inspection records revealing known hazards
  • Employee complaints about dangerous conditions

Expert Testimony: MTA slip and fall cases often require expert witnesses:

  • Safety engineers to identify code violations
  • Medical experts to explain injury severity
  • Accident reconstruction specialists
  • Maintenance experts to critique MTA protocols

Compensation for NYC Subway Accidents

Successful MTA lawsuit settlements can provide significant compensation for injured passengers:

Medical Expenses: Full coverage for accident-related medical costs:

  • Emergency room treatment and hospitalization
  • Surgery and rehabilitation expenses
  • Ongoing medical care and therapy
  • Future medical needs and equipment

Lost Income: Compensation for work-related losses:

  • Lost wages during recovery
  • Reduced earning capacity
  • Lost benefits and opportunities
  • Vocational retraining costs

Pain and Suffering: Non-economic damages for:

  • Physical pain and discomfort
  • Emotional distress and anxiety
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Permanent disability or disfigurement

Recent MTA Incidents and Settlements

  •  A 69-year-old woman suffered severe brain damage after falling down a poorly lit subway stairwell. The stairs were found to be hazardous due to inadequate lighting, and she received a $16 million settlement.
  • A video showing commuters repeatedly tripping on an uneven subway step went viral online. Although no one filed a lawsuit, the MTA quickly blocked off and repaired the defective stairwell to prevent further accidents.

Why You Need an Experienced MTA Accident Lawyer

Suing the MTA requires specific knowledge of government liability law and transit system operations. The MTA has teams of lawyers defending these cases and will use every available defense to minimize your compensation.

Common MTA Defenses include:

  • Claiming you were comparatively negligent
  • Arguing the condition was “open and obvious”
  • Disputing the severity of your injuries
  • Challenging the notice requirements

An experienced NYC subway accident attorney knows how to counter these defenses and build winning cases against the MTA.

Time Is Critical in MTA Cases

The 90-day notice requirement makes immediate legal action essential. Even if you’re still recovering from your injuries, you cannot afford to wait to contact a lawyer.

Steps to Take After Your MTA Accident:

1. Seek immediate medical attention

2. Report the accident to MTA personnel

3. Document the scene with photos

4. Get witness contact information

5. Contact an experienced MTA accident lawyer immediately

Contact a NYC Slip & Fall Accident Lawyer Today

Don’t let the MTA’s legal protections prevent you from seeking the compensation you deserve. With proper legal representation, you can hold the MTA accountable for its negligence and secure the financial recovery you need. Poltielov Law Firm P.C. has extensive expertise in slip and fall accidents and is ready to handle your MTA slip and fall case.

Our experienced attorney understands the complex legal requirements for suing government entities. We know how to navigate the notice requirements, gather crucial evidence, and build compelling cases for maximum compensation. Call 718-880-2911 immediately for a free consultation.

We’re available 24/7 to discuss your case and ensure you meet all critical deadlines. Don’t let the MTA escape responsibility for your injuries. Contact us today to protect your rights and secure your financial future.